Header-Logo Ultraorange.net


American Taliban?!

wa_taliban_on_bikes

“The American Christian fundamentalists are nothing like the Taliban.”

The Taliban used football fields to execute people. They enforced stoning and other cruel laws of the Sharia. They suppressed women, they disliked music, drugs and movies - all that fun stuff. A terrible regime of orthodox believers. Agreed the Taliban were terrible.

American Christian fundamentalists so far haven’t killed anyone - their actions are within the law of the land. Physical violence isn’t anywhere near the Talibans bloody actions. So the American fundamentalists are ‘better’ then their afghan counterparts?

Measuring a society or group just by their usage of physical violence is a bad and not very precise tool.

The basic concept of fundamentalism is that their version of ‘reality’ is the only truth that is acceptable. Anything else can (maybe) tolerated, but never accepted.

wa_american-fundamentalists

Visit www.americanfundamentalists.com to view the image in a larger size - and learn some other stuff as well.

But acceptance of plurality is the most important cornerstone of our modern democracies. This very acceptance is shown in the rule of law that everyone is the ’same’: we all have the same rights, the same obligations - although we are different individuals and by no means the same.

Religions fundamentalists and modern states both have laws and rules, which more or less make sense. But the very difference is who made the law: either they are eternal, because they were made by some God or they are in constant development, because they are made by man and still adapted, expanded and changed.

This also shows a very basic psychological element of the fundamentalist: with a rule set given by your eternal Overlord you have a ‘perfect’ and static system to live by. Not much surprise there. Very different to a pluralists society that continuously changes itself. Although your life might be difficult at times you at least know with a fundamentalist mindset what is right or wrong.

wa_american_preacher

We are right! We are right! We are right!

Here we encounter another problem with fundamentalists: anything that is ‘wrong’ according to his/her believe basic system has to be changed. These people are on a holy mission. Now this is very contrary to ‘in the name of the people’ when you want to change society ‘in the name of the Lord’.

In a Democracy you need the consent of the majority, you need to agree. In a fundamentalist system there is nothing to agree on, no need for debate or even change. Anything that comes from the Lord is not open for discussion. This is especially explosive when a Priest or any other Leader ‘claims’ to speak the Lord’s words. How do you ask God if that person is really his Prophet? You can challenge any law, policeman and politician in court, but again there is no discussion with the word of God.

Lets come back to our American Christian fundamentalists. They are much smarter then the Taliban. They won’t use physical violence to change society - they simply change the laws so society has to adapt. Instead of accepting plurality they use lobbyism, votes and money to enforce only their fundamentalist views.

This is one of the greatest weaknesses of Democracy, that it’s very openness to change and populism allows it’s own destruction. Once again it is important to mention the Hitler lesson (Newsflash: Orangeguru says Christians are Nazis). He was voted into power and slowly abolished democratic laws one by one with popular consent until there was only ‘ein Volk, ein Reich, ein Führer’ (one people, one country, one Führer).

How the erosion of American pluralist consent is progressing can best be documented by the fierce fight about ‘intelligent design’ and abortion. Slowly the fundamentalists ideas are introduced and cemented into popular opinion as the only truth in small steps. I especially admire the propaganda and rhetoric’s to actually use pluralism to enforce fundamentalism: hey, why don’t you teach ‘intelligent design’ - it’s just another form of science?!

wa_abortion_fetus

Abortion is wrong / terrible for other reasons - not because your God said so.

But the war on abortion speaks even louder: here pressure groups have been working for decades to enforce their mostly religious point of view onto American society. On PBS.org is an excellent documentation ‘The last abortion Clinic’ that show you how fundamentalist lobbyism can work wonders against pluralism.

So, is there such a thing as an American Taliban? Yes, there is! The methods might be different, but their attitude is very much the same. Most of all over the recent years we can see the ‘just anger’ and aggression against anything liberal and pluralistic getting fiercer and fiercer.

And it’s that religious righteousness I am most afraid of.


Related Posts


Comments

2 responses to:
'American Taliban?!'

I am a Christian and I would like to comment on your article. I will not try to convince you that your views are wrong and that my views are right. I would simply like to applaud you for, as an apparent non-believer in God, standing up for the rights of the unborn. Abortion is a terrible practice, and it leads to a devaluation of life that has ramifications throughout all of our country - and humanity as a whole. When we start to treat life as an inconvenience, as something to quietly “deal” with, I feel that we have lost a huge part of our humanity. I would love for you to come to believe in Christ, but if that is not going to happen right now then I am perfectly satisfied in that you recognize the horror of abortion and how wrong we are to destroy life where it is supposed to be the safest - in a mother’s womb. I will continue to read your blog as I like to have an open minded perspective on the world we all live in. This is a crazy place, and Lord knows I don’t have all the answers. Take care and I wish you and yours peace and direction in this world.

@Stephen: Thanks for your detailed response and your kind words.

Abortion - like the Death Penalty - will always be harsh and complicated topics in any society. I don’t think there is a final solution to these problems - it’s more like an ebb and flow of ideas, morals and laws that have changed so many times.

For our time: rich countries should be able to “afford” to have kids. In many poor countries it’s often a very cynical situation to see kids starve to death, because they can’t get or afford the food.

All the best.

Please leave a Comment:

No fakes and no insults please. Thanks!




Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment. My Spaminator is checking ALL comments.


Best of Ultraorange

Coming soon!
copyright 2005 - 2008 for all entries dieter mueller or the respective copyright holder